Contract Without Privity: Sovereign Offer and Investor Acceptance

2 Chi J Intl L 183
Andrea K. Bjorklund

In the case of an investment dispute, NAFTA Chapter 11 permits investors from one NAFTA Party to submit to arbitration a claim against the sovereign government of another NAFTA Party. This type of arrangement in which a sovereign entity sets forth terms to which any potential claimant must accede in order for an agreement to be made is sometimes termed "arbitration without privity." Yet despite a lack of privity in negotiating the agreement, the parties to an arbitration still have an "arbitral contract." Chapter 11 is best viewed as a NAFTA Party's unilateral offer to arbitrate a specified set of claims (Section A) according to specified procedures (Section B). Arbitral tribunals will best serve NAFTA Parties and their investors by strictly adhering to the requirements set forth in Chapter 11.